Accounting and Business Research Special Issue Call for Papers
Accounting Narratives: Quantification, Storytelling and Sensemaking
OVERVIEW: Accounting-related narratives are found in various media,
and written by various stakeholders. Preparer-created narratives are
now acknowledged as a crucial component of the business reporting
package (IASB, 2010), and the role of the reader in their
interpretation is well understood. Research into accounting
narratives (broadly defined as written or spoken discourse) has been
developing for some time and covers a broad spectrum from large-scale
positivist economics-rooted quantitative analyses, more recently
assisted by computerised linguistic techniques (e.g. Li, 2010;
Schleicher, T. & Walker, M., 2010), to content analysis supported by
theory from the social sciences (e.g. Merkl-Davies & Brennan, 2011),
to finely worked qualitative case studies, using methods from the
humanities (e.g. Davison, 2008).
In the social sciences, the 'narrative turn' has permeated many
disciplines and is associated with a shift away from realism and
positivism (Riessman, 2008). Storytelling is a specific narrative
form of particular significance because stories help people make
sense of events (Gabriel, 2000; Weick, 1995). A range of devices
(such as structure, plot, viewpoint, character and rhetorical
techniques) are employed in storytelling. Yet, narrative theory and
analysis remains a relatively neglected area of accounting research.
This special issue aims to encourage the broad spectrum of research
into narratives. Papers may adopt any theoretical or methodological
perspective, including blended theory papers. These could include,
for example, studies based in economics, psychology, psychoanalysis,
philosophy, (social) linguistics, sociology, literary criticism, and
could be large-scale positivist studies through to qualitative case studies.
Traditionally, the textual material examined has resided in formal
documents such as annual reports, social responsibility reports, IPO
prospectuses, profit forecasts, takeover documents, analysts'
reports, accounting standards and interpretations, statements by
professional bodies and regulatory oversight reports. We welcome new
work on such narratives as well as submissions on aspects that have
been relatively neglected, such as: authorship; the process of
compilation of accounting narratives; issues of language translation;
less-researched media channels and documents (media coverage, social
media, websites, reports of not-for-profit organizations); spoken
discourse (presentations, conference calls, AGMs and other internal
and external meetings or conversations), and the interface with
marketing and other functions.
REFERENCES
Davison, J., 2008. Repetition, rhetoric, reporting and the 'dot.com'
era: words, pictures, intangibles. Accounting, auditing and
accountability journal, 21 (6), 791-826
Gabriel, Y., 2000. Storytelling in organizations: facts, fictions,
and fantasies. Oxford: OUP.
IASB, 2010. Management commentary: Practice statement. London:
International Accounting Standards Board.
Li, F., 2010. Textual analysis of corporate disclosures: a survey of
the literature, Journal of accounting literature, 29: 143-165.
Merkl-Davies, D.M. & Brennan, N.M., 2011. A conceptual framework of
impression management: new insights from psychology, sociology and
critical perspectives, Accounting and business research, 41 (5), 415-437.
Riessman, C.K., 2008. Narrative methods for the human sciences.
London: Sage Publications.
Schleicher, T. & Walker, M., 2010. Bias in the tone of
forward-looking narratives, Accounting and business research, 40 (4), 371-390.
Weick, K.E., 1995. Sensemaking in organizations. London: Sage Publications.
EDITORS OF THE SPECIAL ISSUE: Vivien Beattie, University of Glasgow
(Vivien.Beattie@glasgow.ac.uk) and Jane Davison, Royal Holloway,
University of London (Jane.Davison@rhul.ac.uk). The editors welcome
informal enquiries from authors.
PAPER SUBMISSION PROCEDURE: Submission deadline: 31st March 2014.
Manuscripts should be submitted online at
http://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/abr. Author guidelines can be found
here. All papers will be reviewed in accordance with ABR's normal
processes. It is anticipated that this special issue will be published in 2015.
Posted 7/8/13